Destination Comparison
Shetland vs Orkney
Britain's two northernmost island groups — both offer aurora, wildlife, and dramatic scenery, but with very different characters.
✓✦5/10
Aurora Score
✦4/10
$115/day
Daily Budget
✓$110/day
Moderate 🛤️
Accessibility
Moderate 🛤️
Oct, Nov, Dec, Jan, Feb, Mar
Best Months
Oct, Nov, Dec, Jan, Feb, Mar
✓14h
Dark Hours (Winter)
13h
Subarctic
Region
Subarctic
✓9 types
Activities
8 types
Our Verdict
Shetland wins on aurora frequency and Norse character; Orkney wins on Neolithic monuments and easier access
Choose Shetland if:
Wildlife enthusiasts, aurora chasers, and those drawn to Viking heritage and dramatic cliff coastlines
Choose Orkney if:
History lovers who want UNESCO Neolithic sites, accessible ferry routes, and a gentler island experience
Scotland
Shetland
Wildlife lovers and culture seekers wanting Britain's most dramatic northern lights experience combined with Norse heritage
Scotland
Orkney
History lovers and photographers wanting aurora as a bonus over extraordinary Neolithic landscapes